With nearly 2,000 votes over four rounds of competition, Herald Leader readers and eaters chose Spalding Bakery as their best shop for grabbing cakes in and around town.
The bakery, located at 760 Winchester Road in Lexington, beat our other competitor, Parlor Donuts, by a landslide. Spalding’s got 197 votes in our last round, while Parlor got 20 votes, or 9%.
A family-owned business that has been in business since 1929, according to its website, Spalding offers a variety of classic, yeast, and stuffed cakes. Plus, you can cut up apple pies, cinnamon rolls, cupcakes and more. They also serve custom cakes and other desserts upon request.
Our bracket competition was just for fun, and meant to highlight fan-favorite local businesses around town.
If you missed it, we also have a contest on the best small libraries. Tell us what you want us to highlight next with an email to [email protected]
Donut slice under review
In case you missed any slice of a donut, here’s how to shape it.
first round: Spalding’s Bakery, Magee’s Baking Co., North Lime Coffee & Donuts, Frank’s Donuts, Parlor Donuts, Donut Days Bakery, Doughdaddy’s Donuts, OMG Donuts, Burke’s Bakery and Delicatessen, Krispy Kreme, Daylight Donuts, Dunkin’ Dons, Southern Glazed Dons, Best Glazed Sweet Creations Bakery, Daily Donuts
second round: Spalding’s Bakery, Parlor Donuts, Magee’s Baking Co., North Lime Coffee & Donuts, Frank’s Donuts, Doughdaddy’s Donuts, OMG Donuts, Donut Days
Third round: Spalding Bakery, Parlor Donuts, Maggie’s Bread Company, Donut Days Bakery
Fourth round: Spalding Bakery, Parlor Donuts
winner: Spalding Bakery
Best donuts in Lexington, Kentucky
If you’re hungry for a donut after reading this, you’re in luck – here’s a brief description of all the stores we’ve featured and where you can find them.
Frank’s Donut: Frank’s Donuts is located on Third St. and offers menu offerings that range from classics like old-fashioned buns to stuffed specialties, like bear claws. Prices are low, too, with regular donuts coming in at less than a dollar. Site: 549 E. Third St., Lexington, KY 40508
Spalding Bakery: In business since 1929, when the founders began tossing cupcakes out of their home, Spalding now sells handcrafted cupcakes from Winchester Road. In addition to classic cakes, it also offers other types of sweets. Site: 760 Winchester Road, Lexington, KY 40505
North Lime Coffee and Donuts: Located in the renovated Greyline Station, North Lime advertises “handcrafted coffee and life-changing donuts.” The donut flavors are a little less traditional, and they also offer vegan options. The company has other locations in Clay’s Mill and Old Louisville. Site: 101 West Loudon Ave., Suite 160, Lexington, KY 40508
Parlor Donuts: Although the company recently opened a location in Jacksonville, Florida, cake lovers in Lexington can find a local parlor on Euclid Street. The outfit offers interesting flavors and even dog-friendly cakes, according to the company’s Facebook page. Site: 630 Euclid Ave., Lexington, KY 40502
Donut Days Bakery: Another longtime donut dish in town, Donut Days has been serving since 1972, according to its Facebook page. They advertise fresh cakes and a variety of other sweets. Site: 185 Southland Drive, Lexington, Kentucky 40503
OMG Donuts: A new donut shop in town has been a hit so far with customers buying the $1.19 classic donut along with croissants, bagels, coffee and more. The company shares menu items and updates on its Facebook page. Site: 3449 Buckhorn Drive, Lexington, KY 40515
Maggi Baking Company: Magee’s offers not only cake, but many other menu offerings that include breakfast and lunch. Yeast, cake and long john cake are offered in different flavors. Site: 726 E. Main Street, Lexington, KY 40502
Dougdadi Donuts: Doughdaddy’s offers a selection of fried pastries from the Versailles location. Advertises fresh donuts throughout the day (even giving away one free with gas refill), with operating hours from 6am to 9pm Site: 3325 Lexington Rd, Versailles, KY 40383
Southern Glazed Donuts: Located in Georgetown, Southern Glazed sells a variety of cakes starting at 5am. Site: 403 S Broadway Street, Georgetown KY 40324
Sweet Creations Bakery: An online listing for Sweet Creations advertises a number of stuffed cakes, among many other pastry items. If you’re in the mood for something delicious, the company offers options accordingly. Site: 2312 Palumbo Drive, 110, Lexington, KY 40509.
daytime donut: Located in Nicholasville, Daylight has a wide selection for those who love sweets, including brightly colored specials and holiday-themed treats. Site: 1020 N. Main St., Nicholasville, KY 40356
daily donuts: Also in Nicholasville, Daily Donuts offers a variety of donuts as well as several breakfast sandwiches, smoothies, and drinks. Site: 908 S. Main Street, Nicholasville, Kentucky 40356
Bourke’s Bakery and Appetizers: If you’re out in Danville, you might be a Burke sponsor. The shop offers donuts, donut pits, donuts and more. Site: 121 W Main Street, Danville, Kentucky 40422
Best donuts: For those in Richmond who are in desperate need of a donut, Best Donuts offers quite the variety. Private business updates and closings through her Facebook page. Site: 711 Big Hill Ave., Richmond, KY 40475
Crispy Cream: With about 1,400 stores, Krispy Kreme operates locally off Richmond Road. The chain is best known for its classic glazed donut and the “Doughnut Hot Now” label. Site: 2893 Richmond Street, Lexington, Kentucky 40509.
Duncan: Chain Dunkin’ has at least three locations around Lexington. The company still serves donuts, although they have dropped them from their name, along with many breakfast items and drinks. Locations: 316 E. New Circle Road, Lexington, KY 40505; 1306 Broadway Street, Lexington, Kentucky 40504; 2213 Versailles Rd., Lexington, Kentucky 40504.
Rex White Light Cajun Restaurant: A reader alerted us to Rick’s presence after our arc was posted. The Bridge Street Frankfort website offers an extensive menu, including beignets. Site: 114 Bridge Street, Frankfurt, KY 40601.
This story was originally published May 23, 2022 10:07 a.m.