Somerville and Cambridge have no shortage of unique and creative ice cream parlors. From Gracie’s Ice Cream in Union Square to the Forge Baking Company, housed in a former warehouse, choices abound for high-quality frozen desserts.
We asked readers to identify their favorite ice cream parlors in Somerville and Cambridge, and more than 1,000 people responded.
We’ve put together this guide to Boston.com readers’ favorite ice cream stores in the area, including a map and a full list of all recommendations. Take a peek, and you may be inspired to get the scoop.
5. Christina’s Homemade Ice Cream
1255 Cambridge Street, Cambridge
Don’t be fooled by Inman Square’s unassuming facade: Christina offers flavors of adventure. Carrot cake, burnt sugar, and Bailey’s Irish Cream are some of the unique options on the menu, while, depending on the season, the shop sometimes also offers pumpkin, egg, or mint. Christina received 8% of the vote. Reader Noah E of Cambridge was impressed by the creative versatility and “impeccable emotion,” while Mara K. From Roslindale she looks forward to tasting fresh rose ice cream every year. Jane from Arlington said, “Whenever they get it, I always order the ginger ice cream. It’s sharp and decadent and reminds me of the roots of the spice shop.”
Where to get the best ice cream in Boston
27 places serving delicious ice cream sundaes
4. Creamy honey
1702 Massachusetts Street, Cambridge
Three words: Ice cream tacos. Cambridge’s Honeycomb disc is a small selection of artisan ice cream parlors, but Taco Tuesdays allows guests to try a selection of concoctions; For example, the strawberry cheesecake taco was a special recently. On the seasonal menu, expect flavors like basil goat cheese, cherry port vanilla, and Thai tea sweetened with condensed milk. Honeycomb got 16% of the vote. Keren J of Medford said, “The chocolate straacciatella milkshake is divine. Seasonal flavors like the peanut butter pretzels, with the pretzels filled with homemade chocolate peanut butter, are delicious. The flavors are creative, gourmet, and sometimes unusual in an exciting way. They make waffle cones.” their fresh.”
3. JP Likes
In our guide to Boston’s best ice cream, the JP Licks empire is a hit, coming in as readers’ top pick, and it’s no surprise that the Somerville and Cambridge chain stores are almost just as popular. JP Licks received 18% of the vote, and was honored for its brilliance and classic flavors, such as cake, cream, coffee, and mint chips. Reader Patti T, from Jamaica Plain, said she enjoys their sundae, especially with the rum and raisin ice cream. An anonymous voter shouted “Oreo peanut butter frappe or Oreo ice cream with chocolate sprinkles! Great flavors, and everyone is so friendly!”
2. Toscanini Ice Cream
159 First Street, Cambridge
This gourmet coffee shop and ice cream parlor may serve up homemade flavors like honey lavender and banana, but it’s B3 that really keeps readers hooked. This mixture of brown butter, brown sugar, and brownies is a favorite of Boston.com reviewers, with one describing it as “the best flavor in Boston.” Toscanini’s, which one reader said offers “delicious, unique flavors and freshly-frosted ice cream that’s silky smooth,” received 21% of the vote. Meanwhile, Foxborough’s Kali P. said: “Toscanini always has new, great creative flavours, but we’re all deeply attached to our longtime favorites. Mine are kulfi and nocciolata, but ginger molasses and burnt caramel have craving fans in my house.”
1. New City Microcreamery
403 Massachusetts Street, Cambridge
What New City Microcreamery is really about is its amazing texture. These shops use a liquid nitrogen process to freeze the cream, giving delicious desserts that create a remarkably smooth consistency. But that’s not the only reason why readers voted New Town as their top pick, giving it 24% of the vote. And the original flavors were celebrated by fans, who specifically referred to the flavor of baklava, which uses a honey base with a nut-honey filling and pieces of filo dough. They also advised visitors to try the poppy seeds, lemon, and pretzels and cream, which have a salty-sweet cream base.
Brookline’s Reader AG said, “I’m probably the biggest fan of the new town in the world. I’ve tried just about every flavor on their menu, and I firmly believe you can’t go wrong. Their chocolate ice cream sets every other chocolate ice cream I’ve ever shamed, And I like the other chocolate ice cream so much! But they’re nowhere near as high as the new town is. Going to the new town is always fun because there are constantly new flavors that I can try…”
Here is a list of ice cream spots recommended by readers in Somerville and Cambridge:
- BerryLine, Arrow St., Cambridge
- Christina’s Homemade Ice Cream, 1255 Cambridge Street, Cambridge
- Forge Ice Cream Bar, 626 Somerville Ave. , Somerville
- Gracie Ice Cream, 22 Union Square, Somerville
- Cream Honeycomb, 1702 Massachusetts Street, Cambridge
- JP Licks, 4 College Ave. A, Somerville
- Lizzie’s Ice Cream, 29 Church Street, Cambridge
- New City Microcreamery, 403 Massachusetts Ave. , Cambridge
- Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream, 808 Memorial Drive, Cambridge
- Tipping Cow Ice Cream, 415 Medford Street, Somerville
- Toscanini Ice Cream, 159 First Street, Cambridge
Subscribe to The Dish
Stay up-to-date with the latest food news from Boston.com.